SJF Kung Fu School provides short-term and long-term authentic Chinese Kung Fu training to international students around the world.
Many beginners start Chen Style Tai Chi silk reeling with a sincere effort to make the arms draw smooth circles. Then the knees begin to feel pressure. The reason is usually simple: the circle is being turned by the knee joint rather than carried from the feet, hips, waist, shoulder, elbow, and hand.
The first goal is not a large movement. It is to make a small, connected circle while the knees remain quiet, supported, and pointed in the same direction as the toes. When this is clear, silk reeling becomes a method for organizing the whole body rather than a repeated arm exercise.
At SJF Kung Fu School, beginning students learn Tai Chi foundations before being asked to memorize longer sequences. This order matters. A form can hide an unstable knee for many repetitions; a slow standing circle makes the source of the movement easier to see and correct.
For a beginner, the intended result is modest and clear: you should be able to make several slow circles on each side without knee twisting, sharp discomfort, gripping in the hips, or losing your balance. Do not chase a low stance or a wide range of motion first. A smaller circle with clean structure is the better starting point.
Silk reeling asks the lower body to receive and return pressure. If the feet, knees, and hips have not been organized first, the upper body often compensates. Take a few minutes to set the frame before adding rotation.
A useful readiness check is this: can you slowly shift a little weight from one foot to the other without either knee falling inward? If not, do not add spiraling yet. Stay with a smaller weight shift and use a higher stance.
Standing work can help students feel this quiet lower-body support before moving. Zhan Zhuang practice is especially useful when the legs shake, the feet feel disconnected, or the shoulders tense during slow movement. It is not a replacement for silk reeling, but it can make the basic stance easier to maintain.
The knee is designed to bend and extend with only limited rotation. In silk reeling, rotation should be guided mainly by the feet pressing into the ground, the kua opening and closing, and the waist turning as one part of the body. Beginners often force the circle into the knee when they turn the pelvis while the foot and lower leg remain fixed.
| Body area | Common beginner error | What to do instead | Immediate self-check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stance width | Standing too narrow, so the pelvis has no stable base and the knees twist to create the circle. | Use roughly hip-width spacing for basic parallel-foot practice. Widen only enough to feel each foot clearly. | You can shift slightly right and left without the knees touching or collapsing inward. |
| Kua opening | Turning the thigh from the knee while the hip crease stays tight. | Let the pelvis make a small turn from the hip creases. Keep the sitting-back feeling light and even. | You feel movement near the hip folds, not a twisting pull at the knee joint. |
| Foot pressure | Rolling to the inside edge of the foot or lifting the heel to create extra range. | Keep the whole foot in contact with the floor and distribute pressure through heel, big-toe area, and little-toe area. | The foot does not rock, and the arch does not collapse toward the floor. |
| Knee direction | Allowing the knee to point inward while the toes remain forward. | Reduce the depth of the stance and guide the knee toward the toe direction. | The kneecap stays over the foot rather than drifting toward the opposite leg. |
| Waist rotation | Turning the shoulders first and dragging the hips behind them. | Let the feet and kua begin the change, then allow the waist, torso, and arm to follow. | The arm circle feels carried by the body instead of pulled by the shoulder. |
The conclusion is practical: if rotation causes knee discomfort, make the stance higher, make the circle smaller, and reduce the amount of turning. This approach fits beginners and returning practitioners rebuilding their base. It does not apply as a substitute for clinical assessment when there is swelling, instability, a recent injury, or pain that remains after stopping practice. In those cases, seek advice from a qualified health professional before training further.
Do not try to “open the kua” by pushing the knees outward with force. The hip crease should release because the pelvis settles and the legs support it. If the knees are pushed wide while the feet cannot support that angle, the strain simply moves elsewhere.
Begin with a front-facing, two-foot stance. This is easier to inspect than a deeper bow stance. Practice slowly enough that you can stop at any point in the circle without falling, gripping, or losing knee alignment.
Stand with your weight approximately centered. Feel three areas of each foot: heel, big-toe area, and little-toe area. You do not need to press hard. You only need to know whether one edge of the foot has lifted or collapsed.
Success looks like: your feet feel broad and quiet.
Likely failure: you grip the floor with the toes. This often stiffens the ankles and makes the knee work too hard. Let the toes lengthen on the floor instead.
Allow a little more weight to settle into the right foot. At the same time, let the right kua receive the weight. Turn the waist a small amount to the right without forcing the right knee inward or outward. The movement should be so small that an observer might first notice the torso rather than the knee.
Success looks like: pressure becomes slightly fuller in the right foot while the right kneecap still follows the toes.
Likely failure: the knee turns before the pelvis. If that happens, return to center, reduce the turn by half, and let the right hip crease soften before moving again.
As the waist turns right, allow the hands to trace a small outward-and-upward portion of a circle. Keep the elbow heavy and bent. The shoulder should not lead. Think of the hand as the visible end of a movement that began at the foot.
Now reverse the direction: settle a little toward the left foot, receive through the left kua, turn gently left, and allow the hands to return through the other half of the circle.
Success looks like: the arms move because the torso moved. The hands do not outrun the feet and waist.
Likely failure: the hands travel much farther than the waist. Make the arm circle smaller until the lower body and upper body arrive together.
Breathe naturally through the movement. Some students find that a soft inhale accompanies the opening portion of the circle and a soft exhale accompanies the returning portion. Treat this as an observation, not a rule to force. Held breath usually adds neck, chest, and shoulder tension.
For students who habitually raise the chest or tighten the abdomen, quiet Qi Gong practice can offer a useful complement. The purpose is not to produce a special sensation. It is to learn whether the body can remain settled while attention stays present.
Silk reeling is repetitive by design. That is why a small error can become familiar quickly. Use the following list after every few repetitions instead of waiting until the end of a long practice.
A short mirror check can help, but do not become dependent on looking at yourself constantly. Use the mirror for a few repetitions, then look forward and feel the feet. If possible, record a side and front view. In the front view, check whether the knees repeatedly drift inward. In the side view, check whether the torso leans forward as the arms rise.
After practicing several slow repetitions each way, stop in the center and test the result. A useful practice session leaves you with more awareness of the feet and hips, not more effort in the knees.
| Completion check | What it suggests | What to revisit if it fails |
|---|---|---|
| Both feet stayed flat and quiet. | Your base supported the rotation. | Reduce stance depth and check toe gripping. |
| Knees tracked with the toes. | The lower leg was not being used as the main turning point. | Make the waist turn smaller and release the kua first. |
| Hands followed the body without shoulder tension. | The circle was connected through the torso. | Lower the arms and soften the elbows. |
| You could pause anywhere in the movement. | You were controlling the weight shift rather than swinging through it. | Slow down and shorten the circle. |
| No sharp or increasing knee discomfort appeared. | The practice level was suitable for that session. | Stop if discomfort develops; restart later with a higher stance or seek professional advice where needed. |
Do not measure progress by how far you can turn. Measure it by whether the body stays coordinated when the movement is slow. Chen Style Tai Chi has deep methods, but its first lessons are direct: root through the feet, guide through the kua, turn through the waist, and let the hands express what the body has already organized.
Correcting knee-driven rotation is easier when an instructor can see the angle of the feet, the quietness of the knees, and the timing of the waist. Master Shen Jiangfei, founder and head instructor of SJF Kung Fu School, is a descendant of Liuhe Quan and an 11th-generation inheritor of Chen-style Tai Chi. His teaching includes foundational work for students before they move into longer material.
This matters for students who have learned from videos but cannot tell whether their rotation begins in the hip crease or the knee. Andrew Williams from the United States trained Tai Chi, Zhan Zhuang, and Dao Fa with his son for 30 days. He described the period as life-changing for physical, mental, and spiritual strength. His experience also shows the value of staying with basic practices long enough for their details to become clear.
Students may begin with a focused One Week Kung Fu Course when they need direct correction on stance, Tai Chi, and related foundations. Those who need more repetition before moving into forms can consider a longer schedule. The school has a 200㎡ indoor training center, allowing year-round practice when outdoor conditions are not suitable.
Silk reeling should leave you more settled than strained. Keep the circle small, let the feet support the hips, and allow the knees to remain followers rather than drivers of the turn.
You need to pay a $100 deposit in advance. This deposit will be applied toward your school fees. Get Unique Customized Kung Fu Water Bottle for Free!
WhatsApp